Discover Wildlife

Back to List

We'll See You in Court

Magazine

July 1, 2014
By Genesee Keevil

Thomas Berger is headed north again, this time to argue for greater protection for the Peel River watershed.

The Peel River watershed, in the northeast corner of Yukon, is one of North America’s largest intact wilderness ecosystems. Here, grizzly bears outnumber people 100 to one. No roads lead into
the region, roughly the size of Scotland, and few Yukoners have ever seen it. But for all its remoteness, the Peel River watershed is a cornerstone of Yukon’s identity — a testament to pristine northern environments.

Today, it is also the subject of a lawsuit before the Yukon Supreme Court, which may lead to a landmark legal decision for both conservation and aboriginal rights.

The suit has been brought by Yukon First Nations over a recent territorial government decision to open large tracts of the Peel watershed to resource development, despite the outcome of a land-use planning process established under Yukon land claims. Leading the arguments? Thomas Berger, the retired British Columbia judge who oversaw the historic Mackenzie Valley Pipeline Inquiry in the 1970s and many more groundbreaking aboriginal rights cases.

“This is a lawsuit nobody wanted to bring,” Berger said during a press conference earlier this year to announce the suit. “But the Yukon government has forced these plaintiffs to go to court not
only in defence of First Nations and environmental values in Yukon, but also to uphold principles entrenched in the Constitution.”

The background to this story begins in 2004, with the formation of the Peel Watershed Planning Commission, established under the Yukon land claims process to develop a land-use plan for the Peel area. In 2011, the watershed commission released its final recommendations, calling for permanent protection of 55 per cent of the watershed. A further 25 per cent was to be protected on an interim basis, while the remaining 20 per cent would be open to a variety of uses, including resource development.

In January of this year, the Yukon government announced its intention to implement a land-use plan for areas not owned by First Nations under land claims that considerably reduces the level of
protection recommended by the commission. Under its proposal, only 29 per cent of the Peel watershed would receive permanent protection, while 44 per cent would be designated as “restricted use
wilderness,” which would permit resource development under specific conditions. The remaining areas would be open for industry, meaning as much as 71 per cent of the watershed not subject to land claims would potentially be available for industry.

For the communities behind the lawsuit, the government proposal flies in the face of the watershed commission’s work. “The Yukon government discarded years of work done by the Peel commission,” Berger said of the government’s plan. “It’s ignoring the views of First Nations, Yukoners and affected communities.”

For its part, the Yukon government argues its plan does more to recognize existing mineral interests in the region and, through cautious management of future development, will achieve conservation
goals while creating economic opportunities.

The big question, however, is whether the Yukon government — right or wrong — even has the authority to unilaterally undo the work of the watershed planning commission. When the case goes to trial in Yukon Supreme Court this month, Berger will argue that the territorial government decision does not stand up under Canadian law, given the watershed commission’s foundation in constitutionally protected land-claim agreements.

“This is the first real test whether governments are obliged to live up to those land-claim agreements entrenched in the constitution of Canada,” Berger said, “or whether it was all just a glorified photo op.” The Yukon Supreme Court is scheduled to start weighing that question on July 7.

 

 Reprinted from Canadian Wildlife magazine. Get more information or subscribe now! Or, get your digital edition today! Preview digital copy »

Canadian Wildlife July August 2014 Feature Story Leading the Charge
Canadian Wildlife: July/August 2014

In the July/August 2014 issue of Canadian Wildlife: Leading the Charge, The Oasis, Fallen Angels, When did dogs evolve from wolves and much, much more. More »

"Flowers of Our Garden" Colour Screen Saver
For those who are missing the colours of the growing...
26 Things You Can Do To Protect Wildlife
Wildlife conservation starts with each one of us — it...
A Backyard Frog Guide for New Brunswick
Blossoming frog enthusiasts in New Brunswick will soon...
A Real Bird’s-Eye View
In his new book — and many others — author Jamie Bastedo...
A Rocky Future for the Northern Pacific Rattlesnake
With help from CWF, researchers at Thompson University...
A Woodland Wonder
Getting a Headcount for the Woodland Turtle Is Harder...
Activites
Take a look at these wildlife and conservation activities...
American robin's nest
American robin's nest
Apple Blossoms
Download this apple blossoms wallpaper.
Avoid the Bags!
avoid the bags game
Backing the Burrowing Owl
CWF funding is working towards helping the world’s...
Backyard habitat
Biting Bugs? Fight Back
Banding Birds in the Yukon
CWF Helps Determine Migratory Bird Populations in the...
Barred owl
Download this wild wallpaper! A resident of deep forests,...
Bats....It would be scary without them
http://HelpTheBats.ca White-nose syndrome is affecting...
Bear Belly
How much food can a polar bear stuff into their stomachs?
Beauty? It’s only skin deep
They’re slimy. They’re ugly. And they’re utterly...
Beaver
Download this wild wallpaper of a beaver. The beaver’s...
Beaver
beaver colouring page
Becoming Beluga
Scientists and tourists flock to Churchill, Manitoba,...
Big Bad Wolf?
By April Overall Wolves Might Be the Villains in...
Birch leaves
Birch leaves
Bird Banquets
Students will conduct an experiment to determine which...
Bird Feeding handout
Bird Feeding handout
Bird Watching - A Healthy, Happy Hobby
Probably 10 per cent of the people in the western world...
Bison
Download Bison wallpaper
Biting Bugs? Fight Back
Spring has sprung, and with its return are biting...
Black Widow Spider
This month we’re featuring this illustration of a spooky...
Blue Jay
Download this wallpaper of Blue Jay
Bluebells
Download this bluebells wallpaper.
Bobcat
Download this wild wallpaper of a Bobcat.
Bull Shark
Bull Shark
Bull Shark
Bull Shark
Bullfrog Blues
Vancouver Island’s got ’em. Biologist Stan Orchard says...
Bumblebee
Download this Bumblebee wallpaper.
Bun in the Oven
What makes human pregnancy different from our wild...
Butterfly
Download this butterfly wallpaper.
Call It A Start
Last winter, the federal government began developing a...
Canada Goose
Download this wallpaper of a Canada Goose in fall.
Canada Goose
canada goose colouring page
Canada needs to break its pattern of unfulfilled commitments to protect wildlife
The 2013 Fall Report of the Interim Commissioner of the...
Caribou
Download this wild wallpaper of a caribou.
Caribou: State of the Nation
Caribou are an iconic Canadian species, yet their...
Certify Your Garden Handout
Whether you are limited to a small patio or have hectares...
Chipmunk
Download this wallpaper of a chipmunk
Chipmunk at Pond
Download this wallpaper.
Christmas Tree
Download this wallpaper of trees.
Cold Canids
Which canid species braves the cold better than all the...
Cry Baby
Do belugas cry?YesNo
CWF Bike For Wildlife: Angella Goran
Come on Canada! Join CWF and our Athlete Ambassador...
CWF Garden Tour
Take a tour of our gardens, which feature native plants...
CWF News
Get all the Canadian Wildlife Federation press releases...
CWF Wallpapers
Your desktop is the perfect habitat for this wild...
Decomposition in the Arctic
Canadian Wildlife Federation Gardener Ken Beattie...
Discover our Posters & Handouts
Hang a little wilderness on your wall with one of our...
Discover Your Watershed Posters
Watersheds … your link to Canada’s oceans … explore the...
Doing Right by the Right Whale
CWF meets with DFO to resolve right whale entanglement...
Dove
Download this wallpaper of a dove.
Dr. Sean Brillant on The Great Canadian Turtle Race
It's Turtle Time! CWF Marine Conservation Manager Dr....
Dress Like A Polar Bear
Students research and determine the appropriate winter...
Ducks
Download this wallpaper of Ducks.
Eel Update
Still a Bad Deal for the American Eel
Egg in Nest
Download this wallpaper.
Eggs
Download this eggs wallpaper.
Elk
Download this wild wallpaper of a elk.
Fall in the Garden
Download this wallpaper.
Feature Creatures
Feature Creatures
Feature Nurseries
Feature Nurseries
Feature Plants
Feature Plants
Finding Mr. Right
Not all Female Animals Respond to the Showier of the Bunch
Flicker in Snow
Download this wallpaper.
Freshwater Turtles
Video from Hinterland Who's Who on Freshwater Turtles
Fritillary butterfly
Download this wallpaper.
From Far and Wide
See the boreal forest from a different perspective.
Frost
Download this wallpaper of frost.
Frozen Solid
Which insect can survive -50C...
Gaillardia Aristata
Download this Gaillardia Aristata wallpaper.
Gardening for Butterflies Handout
Nearly 300 species of butterflies inhabit Canada, some...
Golden Currant
Download this Golden Currant wallpaper.
Goldenrod
Download this Goldenrod wallpaper.
Goldenrod and native bee
Download this wallpaper of a Goldenrod and native bee
Great Horned Owl Live Cam
Great Horned Owl Live Cam
Grizzlies Fishing
Download this wallpaper.
Grizzly
grizzly coloring page
Grizzly at Creek
Download this wallpaper.
Grizzly Video
Hinterland Who's Who Grizzly Video
Grow Wild!
Subscribe for Free! Get Wild About Gardening's Grow...
Hammerhead Shark
Hammerhead Shark
Hammerhead Shark
Hammerhead Shark
Hard Hitters
What kind of impact velocity can a red-headed woodpecker...
Haven In The Sky
The thick-billed murre nesting colonies on East Digges...
Help for Fish in Federal Budget
The federal government announced yesterday as part of the...
Here Toad-day, Gone Tomorrow
How CWF Is Working to Change the Fate of the Great Basin...
Here Toad-day, Gone Tomorrow
How CWF Is Working to Change the Fate of the Great Basin...
Hinterland Who's Who: Wolverine
Watch the wolverine from Hinterland Who's Who
Hinterland Who's Who: Wolverine
Watch the wolverine from Hinterland Who's Who
Hinterland Who's Who: Wolverine
Watch the wolverine from Hinterland Who's Who
HINTERLAND WHO’S WHO AT CANADA BLOOMS
Most Canadians who had television in the 1960s or 1970s...
HINTERLAND WHO’S WHO CELEBRATES ITS 50TH ANNIVERSARY
Most Canadians who had television in the 1960s or 1970s...
HWW Species — Great Horned Owl
One of the most widespread and common birds of prey in...
I Love Wildlife Screensaver
If you love wildlife, you’ll love CWF’s new “I Love...
In Harm’s Way
Last summer’s flooding in Calgary put the city’s zoo in...
In the blink of an eye
Roy Hancliff returns with more of his award-winning,...
Invasive Species Encyclopedia
An encyclopedia of pests invading Canadian wilderness.
It’s a Hard Knock Life
Urban wildlife is adapting to life in the city—sometimes...
Jaws
The meanest bites in the animal kingdom
Lace Up!
Celebrate National Wildlife Week by Participating in...
Lady Bug and Bee
Download this wallpaper.
Larry the Loon Lives On
By Mahina Perrot When you help wildlife, sometimes you...
Leatherback Predators
leatherback predators game
Leatherback Seaturtle
leatherback seaturtle colouring page
Leopard Shark
Leopard Shark
Leopard Shark
Leopard Shark
Light Fright
According to the Toronto Fatal Light Awareness Program,...
Little Brown Bat
Little Brown Bats may be small, but they have the largest...
Live Wildlife Videos
Want to have a wildlife moment? Check out these live...
Lucky Charms
Celebrate St. Patrick’s Day with Canada’s Very Own Lucky...
Lydia, oh Lydia!
Do you know Lydia? You should. It’s not often a great...
Making a better Canada by working together
Just one voice can't make a difference and so I don't...
Making Waves to Protect the Right Whale
This past November, researchers embarked on a unique...
Malicious or Misunderstood?
Debunking Myths about the Wolverine
Marine Conservation
In this webinar, Dr. Sean Brillant talks to students...
Mayapple
Download this Mayapple wallpaper.
Migration Mayhem
How many bird species have collided with buildings during...
Migration Refuges
Make your backyard a haven for migrating wildlife.
Mommy & Me
Find out how crucial mothers are in the animal kingdom...
Monarch butterlfy
We’re featuring a monarch butterfly nabbing some nectar...
Moss
Download this wallpaper.
Mount Assiniboine, BC
Download this wallpaper.
Mountain Lady's Slipper
Download this wallpaper of a ladyslipper
Mow, Mow, Mow Your Lawn
How much pollution does the average gas lawn mower emit...
Native Plant Encyclopedia
Growing native plants can be as rewarding as any of your...
Native Plant Suppliers
Find a native plant supplier in your area.
Natural Insect Control Handout
A garden is more than just plants. It may be tempting to...
Navigating Troubled Waters - Wildlife
Humans are not the only living creatures that depend on...
New England Aster
Download this New England aster wallpaper.
Newfoundland’s Cape St. Mary
Your desktop is the perfect habitat for this wild...
Newsmaker: Are the Prairies About to Go Hog Wild?
The spread of wild boars has become a major headache in...
Newsmaker: We're Making Films Here
A Toronto-based company comes up with a solution to the...
Northern Cardinal
Download this wallpaper of a Northern Cardinal
Northern saw-whet owl
Download this Northern saw-whet owl
Ocean Habitats and Wildlife
Dr. Sean Brillant continues his webinar series, talking...
Oeufs dans le nid
Télécharger
Old Bats
1. How long can the little brown bat live? a. 15 years...
On the Prowl
Lynx are a relatively common species across Canada, but...
Orca
Your desktop is the perfect habitat for this wild...
Orca
We’re featuring an illustration of a majestic orca this...
Orca
orca colouring page
Our Beef With Aquaculture
CWF takes a stand for Canada’s fish
Our Encyclopedias
The Canadian Wildlife Federation’s A to Z guides can help...
Owl Gliding
Download this wallpaper.
Park Here
Canada’s increasingly urban society is a threat to its...
Peary caribou
This month we’re featuring this stunning photograph of a...
Plight of the Bumblebee
You can make a serious difference to these pollinators!
Poison on Legs (Eight to be Exact)
Which spiders in Canada are worth keeping an eye on? By...
Polar Bear
This month we’re featuring this stunning photograph of a...
Polar Bear on Ice
Download this wallpaper of a polar bear.
Politics and the Peel
Wild and remote, the Peel watershed is one of Canada’s...
Pollinator Handout
The work of pollinators benefits all of us every day....
Pollinators
Pay homage to the age-old process of pollination, and to...
Porbeagle Shark
Porbeagle Shark
Porbeagle Shark
Porbeagle Shark
Porcupine
Download this wallpaper.
Protecting the Sauger
CWF recently donated $10,000 in funding to the Lac...
Prunus Virginiana
Download this wallpaper.
Pucker Up
Which of the following Canadian species kiss? The...
Puffin and the Iris
Download this wallpaper of a puffin.
Pussy Willow
Download this wallpaper.
Raccoon chewing
Download this wallpaper.
Ready, Set, Snow!
Students will be able to identify, list, and compare ways...
Red fox
Red fox
Red Knot Under Review
Last year we wrote about the threats facing red knots and...
Red squirrel
Download this wallpaper of the red squirrel.
Researching the Human Impact on Grizzly Bears in Alberta
With a $7,500 grant from the Canadian Wildlife...
Robins at Birdbath
Download this wallpaper.
Ruby-throated hummingbird
Download this Ruby-throated hummingbird wallpaper.
Rudbeckia
Download this Rudbeckia wallpaper.
Sandhill Cranes/Grues du Canada
This month we’re featuring Sandhill cranes (Grus...
Save the Bats
Halloween just isn’t the same without bats.
Saving the Steller Sea Lion
They May Be the Lions of the Sea, but They Need Our Help...
Shooting Star
Download this wallpaper.
Shorelines… a Festival of Life
Let’s celebrate the species that are important to our...
Shoveler
Download this wallpaper.
Smarter Than Your Average Chicken-Hawk
By April Overall Think birds are low on the totem pole...
Snow Place Like Home
Students will be able to describe the subnivean (under...
Snow Way to Hide
Students will be able to explain how foxes hunt in the...
Snowmobile Savvy
Through roleplay, students will discover the considerable...
Snowy Owl
Download this wallpaper of the Snowy Owl.
Spooky Night
Download this wallpaper
Stag and Doe
This month we’re featuring a this photograph taken by a...
Status: Northern Leopard Frogs
In May, the Vancouver Aquarium announced it had hatched...
Steller's Jay
Download this wild wallpaper of a Steller's Jay.
Sunflower
We’re featuring a brilliant yellow sunflower soaking up...
Swamp Rose Mallow
Download this wallpaper of Iliamna rivularis.
Take This To The Bank
The concept of conservation offsetting is gaining...
The Birds of the Boreal
By Stephanie Poff Three billions birds call the boreal...
The Devil You Know?
Are grey seals to blame for the failure of the cod...
The Last Stand
Northern spotted owls are the most-endangered bird in...
The Meeting Place
Beluga whales congregate each summer along...
The Mystery Behind the Mask
1. The raccoon gets its English name from the Algonquian...
The Oasis
In the far reaches of northern Yukon, there’s a place...
The Race Is On!
How fast can a coyote run? A. 37 kilometres per...
The Un-Dead
Which snake plays dead to deter predator’s from making...
The Winners' Circle
Some of Canada’s most committed conservationists do...
Tiger Lily
Download this Tiger Lily wallpaper.
Titlark
We’re featuring a titlark basking in the sun. Download...
Tracking Wildlife with UAVs
The Canadian Wildlife Foundation recently donated $5,000...
Trying Times for the Western Painted Turtle
CWF is supporting one of Canada’s most colourful...
Voices of the North
CWFeducation.ca
We ♥ Trees!
Trees form the backbone of our natural heritage. Let’s...
What Are Your Plans for Valentine's Day?
Three wildlife-friendly ideas that’ll make your heart...
What Do We Know?
Recovery planning is even harder when the species is hard...
What is the oldest surviving canid?
A. The grey fox B. The coyote C. The grey wolf
What Kind of Shark Are You?
How do you get along with others?
What Kind of Shark Are You?
How would your friends describe you?
What Kind of Shark Are You?
What kind of environment do you like?
What Kind of Shark Are You?
What’s your favorite seafood?
What Kind of Shark Are You?
How would your friends describe you?
What Kind of Shark Are You?
What kind of environment do you like?
What Kind of Shark Are You?
How do you get along with others?
What Kind of Shark Are You?
What’s your favorite seafood?
What’s Up With DFO?
Fisheries and Oceans is in the crosshairs of government...
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which car best describes you?
Which Pollinator Are You?
3. How adventurous are you?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Which Pollinator Are You?
1. How would you describe your work ethics?
Which Pollinator Are You?
Are you goal-oriented or bold and spontaneous? You may...
Which Pollinator Are You?
2. How would you describe your fashion sense?
While No One Was Looking
A pair of beavers has moved into Stanley Park’s Beaver...
White Nose Syndrome plaguing Maritimes bats
he white nose syndrome appeared in New Brunswick in 2011...
Widget: Caribou
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Widget: Fish
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Widget: Fishers
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Widget: Jobs
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Widget: Money
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Widget: Moose
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Widget: Oil
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Widget: Wood
Embed this widget on your site, favourite social...
Wild About Bats
Wild About Bats is a unique gem in the Wild About …...
Wild About Bats handout
Wild About Bats handout
Wild About Flowers
Order your Wild About Flowers poster today for more...
Wild About Small Mammals
Learn more about 22 of Canada’s small mammals and the...
Wild About Turtles
Learn more about Canada's turtles and the habitat they...
Wild About… Posters
Take a look at our unique series of field-guide style...
Wildflowers
Download this wallpaper of wildflower habitat, including...
Wildlife E-cards
Send Dad a wildlife e-card! You cherish our wonderful...
Wildlife Update — April 2013
The April edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — April 2014
The April edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — August 2013
The August edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — August 2014
Special Edition! The Best of Wildlife Update! The August...
Wildlife Update — December 2013
The December edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — February 2014
The February edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — January 2014
The January edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — July 2013
The July edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — July 2014
The July edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — June 2013
The June edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — June 2014
The June edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — March 2013
The March edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — March 2014
The March edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — May 2013
The May edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — May 2014
The May edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — November 2013
The November edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — October 2013
The October edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Wildlife Update — September 2013
The September edition of Wildlife Update should have been...
Winter Ecology
Immerse your students in questions of wildlife...
Winter Survival
Students will understand what animals need in order to...
Winter Wonders
Students take the part of either humans wearing winter...
Wonderful Whales
North Atlantic blue and right whales are disappearing...
Wonderful Whales
North Atlantic blue and right whales are disappearing...
‘You’ve Got To Be a Little Crazy’
How do you capture video of wild wolverines? If you’re...